How to Spot Authentic Autographs & Collectibles: A Must-Read Guide for Every Collector

In the realm of autographs and collectibles, authenticity is everything. Whether you're purchasing autographed memorabilia, trading cards, or limited-edition art prints, knowing that your item is the real deal is crucial. With the surge of online sales, counterfeit items are more common than ever. But don’t worry – we’re here to help you spot the fakes and make informed collecting choices! 

Collectibles are more than objects; they’re cherished memories of the fandoms you love and inspire you. A signed poster from Stranger Things or an exclusive art print from Lord of the Rings holds a unique connection that’s hard to replicate (and looks amazing on display!). Genuine items carry both sentimental and monetary value, while counterfeits erode the joy and trust that make collecting fulfilling.  

Whether you’re shopping online or at events, these red flags can help you avoid counterfeit items and make smarter purchases:

• No Certificate of Authenticity (COA): A missing COA is a red flag when buying autographs. Reputable sellers, like Signet Collectibles, provide COAs or witness verification for every signed item. However, keep in mind that COAs aren’t foolproof—counterfeit versions do exist. Always pair a COA with trusted sellers and verifiable provenance to ensure your item’s authenticity.
• Too Good to Be True Pricing: If a rare collectible is unusually cheap, it’s worth questioning why.  
• Low-Quality Images or Materials: Blurry images, uneven signatures, or poor-quality materials can be telltale signs of a fake.
• Vague Seller Information: Always research the seller. Trusted companies will provide clear details about how their items are authenticated.

Learn about our Signet Seal Verification, which guarantees 100% authenticity

Provenance refers to the history of an item—where it came from, who signed it, and when. Collectibles with clear provenance are more valuable as their authenticity can be verified.
Every item purchased from Signet Collectibles comes with detailed provenance, including the signer’s name, event, and date. For example:

• A signed Critical Role art print will include details about the signers and location.
• A The Last of Us poster signed by Troy Baker will list where and when it was signed.

There are several ways to verify your collectible’s authenticity:

• Certificates of Authenticity: Look for items verified by trusted services like JSA.
• Witness Programs: Companies like Signet Collectibles witness every autograph we sell, ensuring its legitimacy.
• Third-Party Grading: For trading cards, comics, and more, services like CGC offer grading and verification.

To help you make informed collecting decisions, here are answers to the most common questions about autograph authenticity:

A COA is an official document provided by trusted sellers or authenticators that verifies the autograph’s legitimacy. It includes details about the signer, the date and location of the signing, and the issuing authority. At Signet Collectibles, every autographed item includes our Signet Seal Verification for guaranteed authenticity.

While some eBay sellers are reputable, the platform also has many counterfeit items. Always check for seller reviews, detailed descriptions, and proof of authenticity via third-party verification.

Here are some quick tips:

• Compare the signature to known authentic examples.
• Look for consistency in pen pressure and flow, which can indicate whether the signature was forged or printed.
• Confirm provenance or COAs from trusted companies like JSA or CGC.

Provenance refers to the documented history of an item, including who signed it, when, and where. It adds credibility and value to your collectible by confirming its authenticity.

Printed autographs (mass-produced signatures) or pre-signed items (reproduced using machines) hold little to no value compared to authentic, hand-signed pieces. For collectors seeking emotional or investment value, authentic autographs are the gold standard.

Trusted retailers like Signet Collectibles ensure every item is verified, with witness authentication or third-party grading. Avoid buying from unverified sources or marketplaces without proof of authenticity.

Buying from a trusted source guarantees authenticity. Here’s why Signet Collectibles is your go-to for autographed memorabilia and exclusive products:

• Signet Seal Verification: Every autographed item comes with a unique QR code and hologram that links to detailed provenance.
• Official Partnerships: Our collaborations with events like New York Comic Con and C2E2 ensure all items are obtained directly from the source.
• Expertise You Can Trust: With years of experience in the industry, we take pride in providing fans with authentic pieces they can cherish.

Collecting is about celebrating your fandom and creating memories—not doubting your items’ authenticity. By learning how to spot fakes and choosing trusted sellers, you can build a collection that’s both valuable and deeply meaningful.
At Signet Collectibles, we’re dedicated to making your collecting journey safe, exciting, and authentic.

Shop Our Collection Today